“ Permanent Capital.” Has a nice
ring to it, doesn’t it? While some of
the definitions differ slightly, permanent capital
represents funds that will not or cannot be
redeemed. Financial institutions depend on “core
capital”, which is really permanent capital
as these funds will not be withdrawn. Usually
composed of the smaller regular savings accounts
of the average depositor, these accounts are
very important to banking institutions, although
the subject is rarely discussed. Of course,
commercial banks and most companies can always
issue stock to generate and/or increase their
permanent capital base. Hedge funds, havens
for many high net worth individuals and institutional
investors, are toying with the idea of establishing
such a category.
Currently at the total mercy of their investors
and banking sources, hedge funds would like
to have access to some personal capital to
level the vagaries of their investors’
whims. Since their chief source of assets
come from wealthy individuals, pension funds,
endowments, and other institutional investors,
hedge funds and their managers are aware that
this particular investment group are decidedly
against learning bad news. Often, at the first
hint of fund downturns, this group will quickly
stand in line with their collective investment
hands out to redeem their money, at times
taking the hedge fund with them.
Since they naturally cannot accept “deposits”
within the banking definition, they may use
classic business strategies like issuing bonds
or going public, either of which approach
would change their identity completely. Hedge
funds have historically used banks to leverage
their assets but this can be an expensive
option when compared with the ability to generate
permanent capital, if it becomes possible.
In fact, raising permanent capital is not
a totally new idea as International Asset
Managers, a closed-end fund with a product
called Alternative Investment Strategies,
was the first of its kind listed on the London
Stock Exchange in 1996. IAM soon had company
when another closed-end fund, Dexion Absolute
(with approximately $1.4 Billion assets under
management), joined it on the exchange.
As the number of hedge fund initial public
offerings (IPO’s) increases, so does
the intrigue, investor curiosity and, apparently,
interest. CMA Global Advisors recently took
its closed-end fund of funds public and raised
$402 Million. Goldman Sachs bested that raise
as they brought its Dynamic Opportunities
Fund to market and generated $507 Million.
Prior to recent IPO’s, hedge funds assets
listed on the London exchange were around
$3 Billion; after recent fundraising, almost
$2.4 Billion, these assets have almost doubled.
Foreign markets are also enjoying similar
results. Look at Toronto, Sydney and Zurich
and notice they are recording over $2.8 Billion
in similar investments, while Amsterdam has
been a favorite hedge fund choice. For instance,
Boussard & Gavaudan generated $562 Million
and Marshall Wace (London) broke the bank
with a €1 Billion raise recently. One
reason for Dutch fund raising popularity is
a result of the ban by the Financial Services
Authority on listing of single strategy hedge
funds. Amsterdam also has fewer restrictions
on short selling transactions. While the Authority
has stated it is considering lessening restrictions
on investment firms, they admitted that changes
of this nature do not happen overnight, with
the best hope being around a twelve month
window.
Additional hedge funds are stepping up to
the plate to offer their menu choices to the
investment world. Across the pond, U.S. hedge
funds are apparently getting the urge to participate.
First to file an IPO was the huge Fortress
Investment Group. With approximately $26 Billion
in assets under management, after the IPO,
Fortress could be valued at around $7.5 Billion.
Another hedge fund leader, Citadel Investment
Group, with approximately $12 Billion in managed
assets, seeks a permanent capital base created
through the sale of $2.0 Billion of senior
unsecured debt to the investment community.
Capital will be the first known hedge fund
to use a debt sale as the source of permanent
capital.
While raising permanent capital is, of course,
a common practice of thousands of companies,
hedge funds are a bit different than most.
This poses a potentially major problem for
investors, regulatory agencies and the market
in general. It shatters the regulatory requirement
that hedge fund investors should be “qualified”
clients with high net worth. But, of course,
IPO’s provide much smaller, less sophisticated
investors the opportunity to participate with
hedge funds, traditionally out of reach.
Since investors with only $5,000-$10,000 could
now own shares of a hedge fund, regulatory
agencies in the U.S. and Europe are concerned
and will most certainly take some action.
Since hedge funds have been the purview of
wealthy investors, who, it is presumed, know
ways to protect themselves, regulators will
be evaluating methods to protect smaller,
less savvy investors. The good news for hedge
funds: Their ability to participate in the
capital and debt markets displays their economic
“maturity” and, to some degree,
stability. The bad news: Further regulation,
directed at protecting the smaller investor,
looms on the horizon, which may limit the
level of IPO fund raises in the future.